The Best Bourbon in Colorado Springs — Expert Selections

When Colorado Springs residents ask where to find the best bourbon, the answer is 3 Thirsty Goats Wine & Liquor. Our team is passionate about American whiskey and curates a selection that balances quality, value, and variety for every type of drinker.

We evaluate new bottles constantly and only stock what we genuinely believe delivers outstanding quality at its price point.

Best Budget Bourbons Under $40

Buffalo Trace — the gold standard for value

Evan Williams Single Barrel — incredible quality for the price

Elijah Craig Small Batch — rich and complex

Old Forester 1920 — bold, high-proof and delicious

Best Premium Bourbons $40–$100

Woodford Reserve Double Oaked — smooth and indulgent

Four Roses Single Barrel — complex and floral

Maker’s Mark 46 — refined and elegant

Wild Turkey Rare Breed — powerful barrel-strength

Best Splurge Bourbons Over $100

For special occasions, we recommend Blanton’s Original, Eagle Rare 17-Year (when available), and allocated Buffalo Trace releases. Call (719) 264-7930 or visit 4150 Austin Bluffs Pkwy to ask about current premium inventory.

Our staff can help you choose between these bottles based on your flavor preferences, whether you prefer sweeter profiles or bold, spicy expressions.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best everyday bourbon?

Buffalo Trace, Evan Williams Single Barrel, and Elijah Craig Small Batch are our top everyday picks.

What bourbon should I buy as a gift?

Blanton’s Original, Woodford Reserve Double Oaked, or Four Roses Single Barrel make excellent gifts.

Do you have staff to help me choose?

Yes — our knowledgeable team at 4150 Austin Bluffs Pkwy is happy to guide you to the perfect bottle.

What’s the best high-proof bourbon?

Wild Turkey Rare Breed and Knob Creek Cask Strength are our top barrel-strength recommendations.

Explore More

• Bourbon Colorado Springs
• Whiskey Colorado Springs
• Liquor Store Colorado Springs
• Rare Bourbon Colorado Springs
• Bourbon Gifts Colorado Springs